First Choice Exteriors LLC
Reviews, BBB data, and alternatives in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
This is an independent RoofVista profile for First Choice Exteriors LLC. We aggregate public data from Google and the BBB so homeowners can compare contractors before requesting quotes. This company has not been vetted by RoofVista.
Trust Snapshot
Google Rating
88 reviews
BBB Complaints (3 yr)
0
What Customers Mention Most
Based on 5 reviews analyzed by RoofVista
Strengths
- Clean job site
- Highly recommended
- Fast turnaround
- Warranty offered
Common Concerns
- Property concerns
Service Area & Details
Location
Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
Services
Roofing
Status
Operational (per Google)
Business Hours
Monday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
How First Choice Exteriors LLC Compares
vs. 20 contractors in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
| Metric | First Choice Exteriors LLC | Chambersburg Avg |
|---|---|---|
| Google Rating | 4.9 | 4.8 |
| Reviews | 88 | 89 |
Customer Reviews
Sharon Rowles
I am so disappointed. I had done my research regarding First Choice and read all the great reviews so I was confident in hiring them to replace my roof. What a mistake this was. Brandon was quick to come out look at the roof and work with insurance to get my roof replaced. that's where the good service stopped. This has been going on since Mid October and I still do not have a completed roof and gutters. Brandon has ghosted us at least 4 times now, with more excuses as to why the work can't be done then imaginable. I called the main office had to leave voice mail only to get a return call from a young lady telling me not to be upset she was there to help....NOT the case, she took the information and never returned my calls. I am so upset with the horrible service I would give this company ZERO stars if possible. I may have to seek legal ramification's to get my roof complete!!
Kye Ehrman
Benny was fantastic and very easy to work with. The process was seamless and very easy. We were lead through each part of the process and any questions were answered. On roof repair day the guys were so respectful, clean, and efficient. Highly recommended!
Penny Lentz
I’m a 76 year old widow living alone. I am aware that many companies attempt to take advantage of women in my situation. Not so with First Choice Exteriors. Chris Guillen inspected my roof, showed me their products, and offered their services at an unbeatable price. His crew did a wonderful job of replacing my roof and, when they cleaned up afterward, left my yard looking better than it did before. I strongly recommend First Choice Exteriors.
david le
Chris was awesome. He did everything possible and worked with the insurance guy to get my roof inspected and approved. Chris came by and showed me everything that will be done and cost. Then showed and explained material and Shingle color to choose from. Work was done in a day and the company offered warranty on their work. Referred to several friends and family who also got approved.
Reece
Thank you Justin for giving us a very reasonable price on our roof 1st of all. Then I want to thank your crew for an excellent fast job ! The crew was awesome , got to our early and went right to work. They completed our roof in about 8-9 hours. Detailed clean up and really efficient . I recommend First Choice Exteriors to anyone seeking to have a roof replacement. You are welcome to have a look at our house anytime. REVISED COMMENT ON FIRST CHOICE , PLEASE READ ! So I was very pleased with the roofing job as stated, However, time had passed and I noticed Damage to our screen slider. I sent pictures to Justin and Nobody Ever Followed up on the damage, you can clearly see when they stripped the roof a shingle ripped through our screen. I think it’s in bad taste to hide from damaged property . All I can say is BEWARE AND INSPECT EVERY INCH OF YOUR HOME BEFORE HE LEAVES
Showing 5 of 88 reviews
Compare This Roofer
See how First Choice Exteriors LLC stacks up. Get instant quotes from vetted Chambersburg contractors.
Get Competing BidsFree, no obligation
Why Compare with RoofVista?
- Pre-vetted, licensed contractors
- Instant quotes based on satellite roof data
- Side-by-side pricing comparison
- 100% free, no obligation
Alternatives in Chambersburg
Teflon Roofing
Chambersburg
Home Source Roofing
Chambersburg
Tip Top Roofing and Siding
Chambersburg
Tuscarora Roofing
Chambersburg
Mighty Dog Roofing of Waynesboro
Chambersburg
Roofing in Chambersburg
Get quotes in ChambersburgIs this your business?
Claim your profile to update info and join the RoofVista network.
Claim ProfileThis is an independent RoofVista profile. Data sourced from Google Places. Last updated January 2026.
Ratings and business data may not reflect current status. Verify directly before hiring.